BILLED as “the greatest collection of Modern British Art ever to come to the market”, the sale of the Evill-Frost collection at Sotheby’s in London did not disappoint.
The evening auction of 30 selected works on June 15 raised
£32.8m, more than double the previous record total in this
category, and a whole series of artists - Edward Burra, Graham
Sutherland, Patrick Heron - were taken to new levels. But the main
thrust of the sale came from the largest and most important group
of paintings by Stanley Spencer (1891-1959) ever offered.
If there was any speculation before the sale whether the market
could absorb such a selection of wacky but high calibre narrative
paintings in one go, it was duly allayed as unprecedented
competition emerged for the Cookham artist.
On the night, six Spencers made over £2m, selling to five
different buyers. The previous record had been set at £1.75m only
three weeks earlier when The Crucifixion sold at
Christie's to London dealer Daniel Katz - a price which now seems
Here again the trade were active, although mostly acting as
agents for collectors.
The first Spencer offered from the rostrum was Workmen in
the House, a well known but little seen oil on canvas from
1935 which was displayed on the front cover of the catalogue. It
easily overshot a £1.5m-2.5m estimate and came down to a battle
between Chelsea-based Offer Waterman and John Robertson who ran the
Bourne Gallery in Reigate until 2010 but now continues to operate
as a private dealer.
Taking instructions on his mobile phone, Mr Robertson eventually
secured the work at £4.2m.
The record lasted 15 minutes. Nine lots later came Sunflower
and Dog Worship, which had a lower estimate at £1m-1.5m but
which went on to sell for even higher sum.
Mr Robertson was in contention up to £3.4m but here the bidding
was then taken up by a telephone bidder and by dealer Richard Nagy
who had flown back from the Art Basel fair to attend the
sale in person.
Mr Nagy ended up as the underbidder as the hammer fell at £4.8m
to the telephone buyer.
The painting from 1937, shown here, was a complex take on the
artist's idea of universal harmony, with a husband and wife shown
in a state of mystical joy and a group of dogs enjoying an
unbothered freedom with their genitalia on full display. To the
right, the artist portrays himself in the scene as he embraces an
enthusiastic Dalmatian with his tongue.
The 2ft 4in x 3ft 6in (71cm x 1.08m) oil on canvas was
originally bought by Sir Hugh Walpole within a few hours of first
being exhibited. Spencer's lawyer, Wilfrid Evill, who assembled the
collection being sold at Sotheby's, was disappointed at having
missed it, but was able to buy it from Walpole some seven years
later for only £100.
The same telephone buyer purchased Spencer's Beatitude 8:
Worship at £3.4m, while The Bathing Pool, Dogs was
knocked down to Offer Waterman at £3.7m.
Alongside the Spencers, the evening sale also delivered a major
jump for a Lucian Freud (b.1922) work on paper when Boat on a
Beach drew bidding from four members of the trade. It was
knocked down at £2.3m to Novella Baroni, who was also thought to be
bidding on behalf of a private client.
A large rise also came for Edward Burra as a UK dealer on the
phone purchased the 1948 watercolour Zoot Suits at £1.8m,
a work showing a group of men newly arrived from Jamaica in
London's Berwick Street.
The Evill-Frost collection itself had been formed by Wilfrid
Evill between 1925 and 1960 - the London solicitor had even
received some of the Stanley Spencers in lieu of legal fees. While
details about his role as an arts patron remain somewhat elusive,
the enthusiasm at the viewing and reaction of bidders would seem to
confirm his remarkable eye.
On his death in 1963, it was inherited by his ward Honor Frost
and it came to the market after she died last year with the
proceeds of the sale going to charitable causes relating to marine
The executors had set either minimal or no reserves on the lots,
allowing the auctioneers to claim a white-glove sale for the whole
As well as the lucrative evening sale, a further £3.26m came
from the 87-lot day sale of Modern British art the following
morning. The third part of the collection, a more traditional array
of decorative arts, furniture and French porcelain, added a further
By Alex Capon
Antiques Trade Gazette is the weekly bible of the fine art and antiques industry. Read articles like this every week in the Antiques Trade Gazette or ATG app. Click here to subscribe today.