THE strong competition that emerged for some of the most exciting pictures at the latest Old Master sales in London helped lift the series and compensated for the lack of interest at lower levels.
The auctions were punctuated by a number of record prices for
quality works in good condition, but elsewhere bidding failed to
take off as the market appeared as selective as ever.
Overall, the auctions at Sotheby's, Christie's and Bonhams made
a combined hammer total of close to £48m (including day sales)
which compared to £52m for the equivalent series last year.
The much-talked-about portrait of an old man by Velázquez at
Bonhams left many in the saleroom underwhelmed
when it sold for a mid-estimate £2.6m. It was knocked down to New
York dealer Otto Naumann who was bidding in the room against
competition from an interested party on the telephone.
More competition here came for a still life by the Dutch painter
Adriaen Coorte which attracted five bidders against a
£300,000-500,000 estimate and sold to Sotheby's-owned gallery
Noortman Master Paintings at a record £1.8m.
The top lot of the week came at Christie's evening sale on
December 6 when Pieter Brueghel the Younger's (c.1565-1638) The
Battle between Carnival and Lent took £6.1m against a
£3.5m-4.5m estimate. It was knocked down to a telephone manned by
Cécile Bernard, director of Christie's Old Master department in
The 3ft 11in x 5ft 7in (1.19 x 1.71m) oil on canvas had last
sold at Christie's in December 2006 for £2.9m where it was bought
by a European private buyer, and so the price here represented a
significant increase over the five years.
Normally the market favours fresh material, but here the sense
that there may be few opportunities remaining to purchase such a
large and busy Brueghel in such good condition appears to have
propelled the price upwards.
Another version of the same subject in the same size by Brueghel
the Younger took £1.75m at Christie's last December but it was not
in as good condition.
Christie's 36-lot sale lasted two hours as records came for two
further Dutch pictures: an exceptional marine by Willem van de
Velde the Younger, which sold to a private Dutch buyer on the phone
at £5.25m, and Govaert Flinck's An Old Man at a Casement
which was knocked down at £2.05m to London-based dealer Jean-Luc
These results boosted the sale's hammer total to £21m (estimate
£18.2m-26.5m) with 26 lots finding buyers.
Meanwhile, Sotheby's sale the following night
made £17.4m, just below the presale estimate with 26 of the 38 lots
The top lot was the pair of Johann Zoffany paintings of the
actor David Garrick which were knocked down for a low-estimate £6m
in the room to London dealers Hazlitt, Gooden & Fox, reportedly
on behalf of The Garrick Club in London - although neither the
auction house or club itself would confirm this.
A record also came for Jan Steen's Card Players in an
Interior despite selling below estimate at £4.3m. The work was
subject to a third-party guarantee.
By Alex Capon
Antiques Trade Gazette is the weekly bible of the fine art and antiques industry. Read articles like this every week in the Antiques Trade Gazette or ATG app. Click here to subscribe today.