SALES in 2008 in Paris saw Sotheby’s and Christie’s occupy the top two spots for the first time – and open up a significant gap on the rest of the field.
After a 92 per cent rise in 2007, Sotheby’s sales climbed a further 30 per cent to €155.2m (£135m), ousting Christie’s from the top spot they had held in France for the last five years. Christie’s sales were down 19 per cent at €150.3m (£131m). But the blockbuster Yves St-Laurent & Pierre Bergé Collection, expected to bring €200m-300m in Paris next month, should see Christie’s back on top of the pile in 2009.
Each firm recorded 18 individual prices of over €1m. Sotheby’s bettered Christie’s by €33.4m (£29m) to €24.7m (£21.5m) for sales of Post-War & Contemporary Art; Christie’s outsold their rivals in Impressionist & Modern Art with €30.4m (£26.4m) compared to €28m (£24.3m).
The Big Two have opened up a sizeable gap on Artcurial who, only last year, ran neck and neck with Sotheby’s. Despite sales of €35.5m (£30.8m) in Modern and Contemporary Art, and an eye-catching €7.6m (£6.6m) from the developing field of Comic Strips, Artcurial’s turnover slumped over 25 per cent to €94m (£81.7m) – although that was still comfortably clear of Paris rivals Tajan, where sales were down 17 per cent at €58m (£50.4m).
The Hôtel Drouot, which hosts most of Paris’s 70 other auction firms, saw combined sales fall 18 per cent to €411m (£357m), with just ten individual prices of over €1m (as compared to 36 at Sotheby’s and Christie’s combined). Piasa led the way at Drouot with sales of €43m (£37.4m), down 12 per cent – albeit after a 34 per cent rise in 2007.
Despite a 28 per cent fall in sales to €13.7m (£15.8m), Beaussant-Lefèvre continued to register impressively healthy selling rates of 89 per cent by lot and 86 per cent by value.
Sales at Pierre Bergé & Associés, which splits activity between Drouot and Brussels, fell 24 per cent to €32m (£27.8m) – just ahead of Aguttes, who are based in suburban Neuilly-sur-Seine and also acquired the dynamic Anaf firm in Lyon during the summer. Aguttes’s total sales of €31.4m reflected a drop of 37 per cent on 2007, when their results were swollen by the exceptional €22m André Lefèvre Collection. Osenat of Fontainebleau, the leading firm in the Ile-de-France, saw turnover down ten per cent at €15.9m (£13.8m).
Sales at Millon & Associés fell 12 per cent to €29m.
It should perhaps be noted that the average fall in sales, of just under 20 per cent, almost exactly mirrors sterling’s decline against the euro over the year.
By Simon Hewitt
Antiques Trade Gazette is the weekly bible of the fine art and antiques industry. Read articles like this every week in the Antiques Trade Gazette or ATG app. Click here to subscribe today.