Latest results now prompt a rethink in London on English porcelain as East Anglian enthusiasts take pride in collecting local factory’s output.
As prices begin to 'correct' in so many over-inflated picture
markets, one wonders if the two major auction houses will again
look to generate revenue from the traditional antiques which a
couple of years ago seemed to offer only small beer.
Should they ponder on the whereabouts of major consignments of
English porcelain they will not have too far to look.
The answer will be found at Bonhams and at places such as the
Beaconsfield Club, Lowestoft, where specialist auctioneer Russell
Sprake sold the collection of the late Peter Scully (1920- 2008) on
Mr Sprake is, perhaps, the most specialised of UK auctioneers,
conducting sales consisting primarily of the bone-rich soft-paste
porcelain made in Lowestoft between c.1757-1801. The Scully
collection ranks among the best he has sold in a quarter century -
and, by and large, the market held up well in the difficult
Suffolk born and bred, Peter Scully started his Lowestoft
collection after retiring as a brewer in the early 1980s, buying at
auctions and through wellknown dealers until relatively recently.
He owned some important pieces.
These included a 5.25in (13cm) jug painted with tulip, rose and
flower sprays by the enigmatic Tulip Painter and inscribed C.
E. Heaman 1776. This piece has appeared in a number of major
collections - the Ruben Levine Collection sold by Sotheby's in
1925; the Wallace Elliot Collection (Sotheby's, 1938) and the
Russell Colman Collection (Sotheby's, 1948) - and had formed part
of the 1957 Lowestoft China Bicentenary Exhibition in Ipswich
conducted by Noel Turner.
Although damaged (it has one long and one short hairline) it had
the potential to break the auction record for a piece of Lowestoft
porcelain which stands at £18,000 paid for a dry mustard pot at
Phillips. However, bidding stopped at £12,000 - the winner being a
No other factory produced so many dated and inscribed wares as
Lowestoft, and in this sale there were four documentary pieces.
These included a 3in (7.5cm) polychrome mug, painted with a
monogram and date, ER 1793,which sold at £3800, and a
41/2in (11.5cm) cylindrical blue and white mug inscribedRobt Howes
1776,which was in the 1957 bicentenary exhibition and sold here at
£2900. Both pieces were damaged: the former with a piece broken and
reglued, the latter with a hairline crack close to the handle.
A 6in (15cm), bell-shaped, blue and white mug, in near-perfect
condition, was inscribed and dated James Crick Shottisham
1773. This mug, made for a resident of a village in the Deben
River valley, was part of a Simon Spero exhibition of 1999.
It carries the decorator's mark number5which is traditionally
associated with Robert Allen who - according to William Chaffers'
1863 work Marks and Monograms on European and Oriental Pottery
and Porcelain - began work at Lowestoft in 1757 as a
12-year-old, rising to become foreman then manager at the factory.
This mug, which shares many of his calligraphic idiosyncrasies,
sold at £6700 (estimate £5000-6000).
As Bernard Watney observed of Lowestoft: "No other English china
evokes quite the same sense of belonging to a particular
It is for this reason that the overwhelming majority of
collectors hail from East Anglia and why they enjoy these sales on
Lowestoft had two pre-Reformation churches at the time of its
porcelain factory: the Good Cross Chapel, which stood at the
southern extremity of the town but was lost to the sea, and St
Margaret's, with its distinctive copper spire, which survives on
the western edge of the town centre.
Robert Browne, the first manager of the Lowestoft factory, is
buried there while Robert Allen produced the stained glass of the
east windows. Both buildings were depicted on factory wares at a
time when the then wealthy port was also becoming a popular holiday
Readers may recall a fragmentary blue and white teapot painted
with a view of St Margaret's dated 1767 and inscribedSC(for Sarah
Crisp) which made £5400 at Hamptons of Godalming in 2005. Included
at Russell Sprake's sale were two printed wares in the Good Cross
Chapel pattern, c.1785.
A small, 4in (10cm), teapot and cover with some restoration took
£1700 (when these auctioneers sold the Charles Goodey collection in
1990 it made around £500), while a saucer in the same pattern in
perfect condition made a punchy £900. An octagonal polychrome spoon
tray, painted in underglaze blue, iron red, green and pink with a
Chinese garden scene took £3000 (estimate £2000-2500) despite a
hairline crack. These so-called Redgrave designs are named after a
family with close ties to the factory.
Above: a small Lowestoft teapot and cover in the Good Cross
Chapel pattern - £1700 at Russell Sprake's sale.
A similar spoon tray in better condition sold at the same price
(plus 20 per cent premium) at Bonhams' sale of the Barbara Leake
collection in March, while the Bond Street saleroom more recently
sold a small 16-sided plate in the same pattern at £1800.
Only three Lowestoft bird models are known. The undecorated
2.75in (7cm) example at Russell Sprake's sale, an unsophisticated
garden bird perched on a tree stump decorated with moulded flowers
and leaves (the tail is heavily restored), is very much in the
style of Bow and dates from c.1780-85.
It had been purchased by Peter Scully from Simon Spero in 2003.
The hammer price was £3600 (estimate £2500-3000). Lowestoft pugs
are typically seen in the white, but the example here, which sold
at £4300, was decorated with pale grey and black markings and
enamelled in green to the collar and the base. A related model of a
cat, c.1780, with similar decoration (and restoration to one ear
and a chip to the foot rim) made £2500 at Bonhams in June 2005.
A 6in (15cm) high milk warmer, or veilleuse, with two
mask heads, scallop shell handles and the decorator's mark for
Robert Allen, had last been seen on the market in 2000 when Bonhams
sold the second tranche of Bernard Watney's collection.
A complete example - perhaps the one which raised £68 when
Sotheby's conducted the D.M. Hunting sale in 1968 - survives in the
unrivalled collection of the Norwich Castle Museum.
The one offered by Russell Sprake had a long hair crack to the
back and was lacking its liner and cover.
At the Watney sale it took £2900: here it made £5800 (estimate
£4000-5000). One of Peter Scully's final acquisitions was a chamber
stick with fine honeysuckle moulding and upstanding ring handle
which he had bought in these rooms last year (November 2007) at
No profit was expected on such a quick turnaround and, indeed,
it sold at £8000.
A Scully purchase from the Charles Goodey collection was a
c.1765-68 pounce pot, painted with trailing flowers and a moth,
which sold at £3900 (it had cost him £1950), while a feeding cup
with printed floral decoration, sold in 1986 for £760 as part of
the John Warrell collection, took £2000.
Copies of the two auction catalogues from the Warrell collection
were offered among the 'warm up' lots at the start of the sale and
Three of the unsold lots were wares from other factories
including a pearshaped pap boat which had been in the Watney
Collection, the Billie Pain Collection (sold at Bonhams in November
2003 at £1600) and in a Simon Spero exhibition of 2004.
At its two previous outings at auction, when sold as Bow, it had
made £1600. Now believed to be Derby, it went unsold at its
estimate of £1000-1200.
Boosted by the success of this sale, in 2009 Russell Sprake has
decided to hold three, rather his usual two, Lowestoft auctions
with sales in April, July and October.
Antiques Trade Gazette is the weekly bible of the fine art and antiques industry. Read articles like this every week in the Antiques Trade Gazette or ATG app. Click here to subscribe today.