THE gargantuan sums of money being spent at the top end of the contemporary art market continued unabated as the latest sales series in New York saw a staggering overall premium-inclusive total of $990m.
So far, the great art market bubble has belied the downturn in
the economic climate and those present at the packed salerooms last
week appeared unaware that a financial crisis and recession were
Both evening auctions at Christie's on May 13 and at Sotheby's
the following night showed that there are clearly still enough
buyers with big pockets ready to spend big money on big names.
Sotheby's 85-lot evening sale on May 14 made a
hammer total of $321m (£172m), within the $288m-357m presale
estimate. It was the highest total Sotheby's have ever achieved and
the fourth highest total in auction history. Only rivals Christie's
have staged more lucrative sales: their contemporary art auction in
June 2007 ($385m) their Impressionist and Modern art auction in
November 2007 ($395m) and the 'Bloch Bauer' sale of November 2006
($491m). All of these three figures include the buyer's
Christie's evening sale the day before totalled
$294m (£158m) hammer from only 57 lots against a presale estimate
of $282m to $398.6m.
Both of these evening sales were comfortably ahead of their
Impressionist and Modern equivalents the previous week, underlining
the fact that contemporary art has now become the auctioneers' most
important financial sector, something also borne out in Sotheby's
first quarter results published last week.
The Sotheby's sale set an auction record for any piece of
contemporary art when Francis Bacon's (1909-1992)
Triptych, 1976 went for $77m (£41.4m) to a private
European collector bidding on the telephone manned by a member of
staff from the London office.
Consigned by the Moueix family, the producers of Château Pétrus
wines, it was estimated in the region of $70m and there were three
interested parties (all on the telephone) after the bidding opened
It has been reported by The Art Newspaper that the
buyer was Roman Abramovich, the owner of Chelsea football club, but
a spokesman for the London-based Russian billionaire declined to
comment saying "We don't get into personal matters".
The triptych itself was the centrepiece at an important
exhibition of the artist's new work in 1977 at the Galerie Claude
Bernard in Paris. Its subject is based on the Greek mythological
figure of Prometheus being tormented by vultures.
Dubbed by the auctioneers as "the most important work by Bacon
in private hands", it broke the previous artist's record of $47m
for Study of Innocent X sold at Sotheby's New York last
It was also the third highest price ever seen at auction. Only
two works by Picasso: Garçon à la Pipe (Sotheby's, $93m,
May 2004) and Dora Maar au Chat (Sotheby's, $85m, May
2006) have made more.
Christie's also offered a Bacon triptych from the same year at
their sale. At 14 x 12in (36 x 31cm), Three Studies for
Self-Portrait was much smaller and, carrying a guarantee, it
sold at a low-estimate $25m (£13.4m).
Demonstrating Bacon's exponential rise in terms of saleroom
performance, this work had sold for $2.9m at Christie's in London
in June 1999, and then $5.1m at Sotheby's New York in November
2005, where it was bought by Richard and Elizabeth Hedreen from
Seattle, who were vendors here.
Christie's also offered Lucian Freud's (b.1922)
Benefits Supervisor Sleeping from 1995 which, selling for
a mid-estimate $30m (£16.1m), became the most expensive work by a
living artist ever sold at auction. Again, this was reportedly
purchased by Mr Abramovich.
The lifesize depiction of 20-stone 'Big Sue', one of the
artist's regular sitters, was purchased from Freud's dealer
Acquavella Galleries in New York by collectors Guy and Marion
Nagger. However, the work was also part-owned by Christie's who
would not elaborate further than saying they had "a direct
financial interest" in the painting.
If Sotheby's took the spoils for Francis Bacon, Christie's
emerged the more satisfied when it came to Mark Rothko
(1903-1970). They offered No.15, a large abstract
with reds and yellows dating from 1952 with an estimate in the
region of $40m. The vendor was San Francisco collector Roger Evans
who bought it at Sotheby's for a then-record $11m in November
Again guaranteed, two phone bidders competed up to $45m
(£24.2m), the second highest price for the artist at auction, but
well behind the reported $140m for No.5, 1948, brokered in
a private deal between collector David Geffen and Mexican financier
David Martinez in October 2006.
The prize Rothko at Sotheby's was Orange, Red, Yellow
from 1956, in which the auctioneers had an ownership interest.
Estimated in the region of $35m, it raised no bids on the night and
was left unsold.
Banksy's (b.1975) run of saleroom success also
took a dent at the Sotheby's sale with Sale Ends Today
from 2006 also unsold against a $600,000-800,000 estimate.
But the sale saw a record for Yves Klein
(1928-1962) when the large gold leaf painting MG
9 from c.1962 sold at $21m (£11.3m), which was then followed
by the French artist's IKB1 that made $15.5m (£8.3m).
Both came from the collection of German collector Walther Lauffs
and went over double their top estimates. They sold to New York
agent Philippe Segalot: there was speculation that he was buying
for François Pinault, the owner of Christie's, who is one of his
Yet more spectacular was the quadruple-estimate $13.5m (£7.3m)
paid for Takashi Murakami's (b.1962) My
The 8ft (2.44m) high sculpture of a naked comic book figure
swirling a lasso formed from his own semen was produced in 1998 and
is currently on view at a retrospective of the prolific Japanese
artist at Brooklyn Museum of Art.
Takashi Murakami is now represented by the Gagosian Gallery but
the work was being sold by his former dealer, Marianne Boesky. With
the artist himself present at the sale, it was bought by an
anonymous buyer on the telephone.
Top lot at Phillips de Pury's evening sale on
May 15 was Jean-Michel Basquiat's (1960-1988) Untitled (Fallen
Angel) that sold at $10m (£5.38m) to a New York dealer
reportedly for a French client. The sale total was $51.3m
The results from the Part II contemporary sales further
bolstered confidence in the market with Christie's making a total
of $69.6m (£37.4m) with an 81 per cent selling rate, and Sotheby's
totalling $91m (£49m) with an 80 per cent selling rate.
The results from Phillips de Pury's part II sales had not been
released at the time of going to press.
By Alex Capon
Antiques Trade Gazette is the weekly bible of the fine art and antiques industry. Read articles like this every week in the Antiques Trade Gazette or ATG app. Click here to subscribe today.