NORTH Yorkshire auctioneers Tennants have cut a profitable niche selling the furniture of local craftsman Robert Thompson, but for their July sale they went one better.
They secured an entire Mouseman commission.
It was back in January when Tennants were invited - with four
other firms - to tender to sell the fixtures and fittings of the
Senior Library at Leeds Girls High School, completed by the Kilburn
workshop from 1933-34 at a cost of £1222.
The school is now moving to a new site and, while elements of
the old building are listed, no preservation order was placed upon
the oak-panelled interior.
Evidently specialist Dianne Sinnott made an impressive pitch:
while her global valuation of upwards of £100,000 was by no means
the highest, her proposal of a showpiece sale fleshed out by
original drawings, photographs and invoices (provided by Robert
Thompson Craftsmen Ltd), secured the 87-lot consignment. No detail
had been overlooked in the 1933 commission - paid for out of an
anonymous gift of £6000 awarded in 1929, the school's jubilee
The wide-ranging assortment of pieces included fitted and
free-standing bookcases, door surrounds, panelling, 16 tables, 87
chairs, an alcove seat, a book trolley, radiator covers, cupboards,
inkwells, pen trays, book troughs, magazine cabinets and library
All had been weathered and patinated by generations of
schoolgirls and with sun damage the only negative to some pieces.
Thirteen of the 87 chairs were carved with not one but two mice.
Each mouse takes around 45 minutes to carve, so two of the little
rodents represent an expensive investment of a craftsman's time and
make these chairs rather scarce.
The most avidly contested examples were those with a mouse
scurrying across the top rail and another protruding on the front
leg. Estimated at £250-350 apiece, they set new price levels for
single Mouseman dining chairs when they sold for up to £2300
Strong yet simple in design, Mouseman furniture is also
practical in size for most people's homes.
Above: a period photograph of the Senior Library at Leeds
Girls High School, completed by the Kilburn workshop in 1934 at a
cost of £1222.
Proving the most commercial offering in the dispersal was a
librarian's pedestal desk, 6ft (1.82m) wide, panelled with turned
octagonal handles and wroughtiron hinges to the drawers and
Tennants were able to publish an original drawing of the design
showing its distinctive eight octagonal feet and castellated
frieze. It left its estimate well behind to make £18,000.
This represents the highest price the auctioneers have realised
for Mouseman since they sold a bookcase with burr oak panels in
April 2001 for £2001. The record for Mouseman remains the
remarkable $70,000 (£40,500) bid at Sotheby's New York for a
two-section, oak cupboard c.1923 with elaborate metalwork by the
Kirkby Moorside blacksmith Will Dawson. The desk, underbid on the
internet, was acquired by the main buyer at the sale: a collector
furnishing a recently-acquired Arts and Crafts house who took 21
Also on the shopping list was a 3ft 4in wide by 3ft 9in high
(1.02 by 1.15m) cupboard, carved to each of the two doors with a
five lattice panel and nine of the small-scale refectory tables
made to a classic Thompson design with jointed adzed tops and two
octagonal legs jointed by a stretcher at floor level.
The cupboard took a double-estimate £5000 and the tables cost
between £5200 and £7000 each - the latter sum tendered for a
particularly well-patinated example with a top measuring 4ft 6in
These were new price levels for what are relatively standard
More unusual were the library steps with a recessed carved mouse
signature, which made £1300, and a book trolley with shaped adzed
ends enclosing three shelves on large steel wheels which sold at
£1700. The trolley was unmarked but was ordered by the school as an
extra in December 1933 and appears in the order book against a cost
of £9 8s.
A number of items lacked the appealing mouse signature but
nevertheless performed well - many selling to Leeds Girls High
School old girls. The numerous simple adzed pen trays measuring 9 x
3in (24 x 8.5cm) were classic memory lane souvenirs and - even sans
mouse - brought bids of between £180-200 per pair. Only the most
architectural of pieces failed to excite the room.
While a large alcove corner seat with two finely carved shaped
ends, one with the mouse signature, went to a bidder from Sussex at
£4200 (estimate £2000-3000), there were no takers for either the
room panelling or the internal and external door frame and doors.
These were only ever going to command £10,000 each if a very
specific buyer was found, but Tennants are hopeful of a private
deal. In all, the Leeds consignment raised £236,000 - and there was
more to come from a mixedowner selection.
Three other pre-War Kilburn lots are of particular note.
Sold at £3800 was a 'monk's' chair of a deep colour that was
carved to the shield back with the initials CK and the
Research at the Kilburn archives identified CK as one Cecil
Kershaw of 200 Harehill Lane, also of Leeds. It took £3800.
A remarkable triple-estimate £3000 was bid for a pair of
bookends, each carved as squirrels eating nuts and each with carved
mouse signature, while, in the wake of the punchy prices paid for a
group of 12 kidney-shaped bar tables from the Masons Arms,
Hopperton in April, another example with a burr oak top was
consigned from the officers' mess at RAF Leeming. It sold at £4200
against an estimate of £2500-3500.
Antiques Trade Gazette is the weekly bible of the fine art and antiques industry. Read articles like this every week in the Antiques Trade Gazette or ATG app. Click here to subscribe today.