Tuesday - 29 July 2014

The market for sporting memorabilia is one of the most diverse areas of the antiques market. This is not just because the range of sports covered - from boxing to bowls - but also due to the vast spread of objects - from fishing tackle to football trophies.

Almost every pastime you can think of is represented in the memorabilia market and numerous sectors of the antiques industry have their own sporting sub-sector: silver, ceramics, paintings, works of art and books, to name but a few.

The items that command the most attention are those that relate to either the early history of a particular sport, or an iconic player, special match or competition.

Written by Alex Capon

Sporting Memorabilia

The market for sporting memorabilia is one of the most diverse areas of the antiques market. This is not just because the range of sports covered - from boxing to bowls - but also due to the vast spread of objects - from fishing tackle to football trophies.

Almost every pastime you can think of is represented in the memorabilia market and numerous sectors of the antiques industry have their own sporting sub-sector: silver, ceramics, paintings, works of art and books, to name but a few.

The items that command the most attention are those that relate to either the early history of a particular sport, or an iconic player, special match or competition.

 

What Do People Collect?

The field is so vast that most collectors focus on one area. There are those who collect all memorabilia relating to their chosen sport, but there are also people who collect items only relating to their favourite team. Others favour particular items like match programmes or cigarette cards.

Most buying is based on an emotional connection to the sport (many serious collectors are also serious fans) but some elements of the market are based on decorative appeal. The former may well include people who pay out for pieces of sporting equipment - a football shirt worn by a club legend or a cricket ball used to hit the winning runs in a famous Ashes series - while the latter could involve items with serious wall-power such as a carved wood fishing trophy or an Olympic poster.

 

Range

The sporting sector offers something for collectors on all budgets. There are plenty of affordable areas, including autographs, ticket stubs and photos, where prices start at just a few pounds.

Ceramics on a sporting theme can also be a low-cost option for new collectors, but at the same time it is remarkable how a golfer, cricketer or footballer can turn an otherwise ordinary 19th century object into something infinitely more desirable.

At the very height of the market, the auction record for a piece of sporting memorabilia was set at Sotheby's New York in December 2010 when the original copy of the rules of basketball sold for a premium-inclusive $4.3m (£2.91m).

 

Sporting E.jpg

Above: three 'point of sale' figures that sold at Bonhams Chester in January 2005. From left to right: Dunlop Man, in almost mint condition, that made £900; the rare Silver King Man, c.1930, took £6600; and the original early 1940s version of the Bromford Man made £750.

 

The Market

The market itself dates back to the days when sport began to develop from a pastime into a form of organised competition. The collecting culture first revolved around gentlemen enthusiasts whose interests tended to focus on traditional sports such as hunting, angling, racing, golf, cricket and tennis.

Golf societies, for instance, began to spring up in the 19th century and they soon started to form their own collections of classic clubs. In 1866 the Union Club House in St Andrews put its collection on permanent display and by 1901 the market had evolved to the point where a large international exhibition of golf memorabilia was held in Glasgow.

As time has gone on, more and more sports have emerged with well-supported memorabilia markets. The relatively new game of baseball dominates the market in the United States. In Europe, during the second half of the 20th century, football and rugby developed into strong collecting areas, to the extent that they are now challenging - and in the case of football exceeding - the more established sectors in terms of their market share.

As with most other sectors of the antiques market, the pitch seems unduly tilted with the top-end items running away in terms of commanding high prices but the middle- and lower-end finding the ground heavy going.

At auctions, the items which generate the most bidding tend to be distinctive in some way, and high-profile consignments with famous associations can sometimes draw press attention that takes prices to truly extraordinary levels.

Collectors know that the best way to ensure that their purchases hold their value or appreciate, is to buy quality, and the current economic downturn has only served to increase this selectivity.

However, supported by an eclectic body of specialist dealers, auctioneers and collectors, the sporting memorabilia market has proved adaptable. In recent times the internet has broadened the scope of the marketplace significantly and encouraged a healthy new following to enter the sector.

  

Golf

 

Perhaps the sport which best demonstrates the selectivity that exists in the market is golf.

The 1980s and 1990s were something of a boom-time for golfiana, with American and Japanese buyers, as well as specialist collecting societies, underpinning the market. However, things have now changed and the collecting societies, such as Spain's Valderrama Golf Club, are no longer the visible force in the saleroom that they once were. After the Japanese economy began to falter in the late 90s and the body of ageing American collectors started to dwindle, the whole market contracted and buyers are now significantly more selective in their purchases.

For instance, a decade ago, standard early 20th century hickory-shafted golf clubs were the dependable stalwart of the saleroom, selling in sets for the equivalent of £20 to £30 each. These clubs are now fetching between £8 and £12 each, and the number of clubs that find buyers at auction is significantly lower.

The same is true of the early balls - the pre-1850 feather balls or 'featheries' and the first gutta percha balls made in a myriad of different patent designs. Vendors of balls that could often command five-figure sums in the 1990s are now having to settle for four-figure returns instead.

However, the flip-side of this means that, for buyers, especially new collectors, there are now plenty of relative bargains to be had.

There are also hopes that China's developing enthusiasm for the sport will yield to a market resurgence in the future - something indicated by the sale of 7000 hickory-shafted golf clubs to a Chinese businessman in April 2009 in a single sale made by an Edinburgh dealer (click here for full story).

Either way, when the right lots come up, the old school collectors, including the big American buyers, will still emerge. For instance, despite the rather patchy performance of Sotheby's sale of the Jeffery B. Ellis collection in New York in September 2007, the overall $2.17m total was a record for a golf-memorabilia auction and the premium-inclusive $181,000 (£93,780) paid for an 18th century long-nosed putter stamped 'A.D.', purportedly for Andrew Dickson (the first club maker to mark his clubs of which only four examples are known), was an auction record for any golf club.

Sporting D.jpg

Above: a bent neck putter from c.1890s used by Willie Park Junior. The club, with its longer than standard 4.5in hosel, was the kind used by Park in numerous Opens, including when he was runner-up in 1898. With a label written and signed by the club-maker Ben Sayers Junior, it sold for £3300 at Bonhams Chester in June 2010.


Football

 

In the UK domestic market for sporting memorabilia, football is the sport that currently delivers the most supply, both in terms of the number of items and their overall value, and the most demand.

Some areas of the football market, particularly the programmes and medals, have been collected for a long time, but others such as shirts, boots and signed photographs have only moved to the forefront of the sporting memorabilia market over the last decade. Traditionally, the club with the biggest collecting following is Manchester United, which is then followed by the London clubs with the largest fan base - Arsenal, Tottenham and Chelsea.

The supply is helped by players from a previous generation selling their personal collections. There has been a healthy crop in recent years, including the much-publicised sale of the collection of Manchester United legend Nobby Stiles at Convery Auctions' sale in Edinburgh in October 2010. 

The top lot was Stiles' 1966 World Cup winner's medal, which overshot its £100,000-150,000 estimate and was bought by Manchester United's club museum at £160,000. The price was the highest for a '66 medal sold as a single lot at auction - eclipsing the £140,000 seen for Alan Ball's medal sold at Christie's South Kensington in May 2005.

Pre-1900 FA Cup and international material remains the most sought after area in football programmes. They continue to see a good take-up.

In November 2010, Graham Budd Auctions (in association with Sotheby's) offered what was believed to be the earliest programme for an England home international match, a game against Ireland on March 2, 1889 held in Liverpool which England won 6-1. Estimated at £6000-8000, it was knocked down at £8400.

The same auctioneer also holds the current record for a football programme - £19,000 for the single sheet from the 1889 FA Cup final held at The Oval, Kennington between Preston North End and Wolverhampton Wanderers - click here for full story.

 

Angling

 

Angling collectors typically focus upon the tools of the trade, related literature and prize catches cased by a taxidermist or carved in wood. The market is truly international (American tackle is a field on its own) but some makers, particularly the famous Hardy firm in Alnwick, have assumed iconic status. Collectors seeking, for example, to collect the numerous variants of the Hardy brass Perfect trout reel, require great technical knowledge and deep pockets to match.

A market movement in more recent years has been the growing interest, in the UK at least, in the coarse fishing reels produced by manufacturers located in Redditch, just south of Birmingham, including Allcock, Partridge, Wilkins, Milward's, Lee, Martinez & Bird and J.W. Young.

Lures, gaffs, nets, tied flies, fly 'reservoirs', creels and (to a lesser extent rods, which are often more difficult to display) add to the collecting variety.

 

Cricket

 

Like fishing antiques, cricketing memorabilia has a long collecting history and enjoys a broad collecting base in both the home market and in the other cricket-playing nations.

The rare survivors from the early history of the game, plus memorabilia relating to celebrated players or matches, provide the 'trophies' in this market. Early issues of the annual Wisden Cricketers' Almanack are notably in consistent demand as witnessed when the MCC sold 110 cricket books at Christie's South Kensington on November 2010, raising in excess of £540,000 towards the conservation and enhancement of the core collections at Lords.

The long history of the game dictates that cricketing ceramics and related works of art do survive from the late 18th and early 19th centuries (see report on the Crump collection) but highly desirable pieces were made by factories such as Royal Doulton into the 20th century.

Ashes memorabilia has a special status for the English and Australian collectors who dominate the market. Bats and balls provenanced to famous games and the caps worn by great players of the pre- and immediate post-War era are avidly collected - the 'baggy green' cap worn by Sir Donald Bradman during the 1948 'Invincibles' tour sold for a record Aus$402,500 at Charles Leski Auctions in Melbourne in December 2008.

 

sporting L.jpg

Above: a Stuart Surridge County Driver cricket bat, signed by the 1948 Australian cricket team, including Don Bradman (Captain), Arthur Morris and Neil Harvey. It sold for £170 at Charterhouse auctioneers in October 2009.

 

Where To Look

Specialist sporting auctioneers include Graham Budd in London, Convery Auctions in West Lothian, Mullock's in Shropshire and Knights in Leicester.

A small number of other salerooms, such as Bonhams and McTear's of Glasgow, have a dedicated sporting department, while others such as Greenslade Taylor Hunt in Somerset, Brightwells in Leominster and Golding Young in Lincolnshire stage regular dedicated sporting sales.

There are also a few salerooms that focus primarily on a specific sport such as cricket specialists T. Vennett-Smith in Nottinghamshire and Angling Auctions in Chiswick.

Numerous other auctioneers sell sporting objects as part of larger sales.

 

Further Reading

Golfing Memorabilia: Memoirs of Mort Olman, the Grandfather of Collecting by Morton W. Olman, 2004. ASIN: B0011Q9760 

The Story of the Golf Ball by Kevin McGimpsey, Kevin McGimpsey in association with Philip Wilson Publishers. ISBN 0856675661 £49hb 

Soccer Memorabilia: A Collectors' Guide by Graham Budd, Philip Wilson Publishers Ltd (July 2000). ISBN-10: 0856675040 

The Football Programme: A History and Guide by John Lister, Tempus (July 2000). ISBN-10: 0752418556 

The Wisden Book of Cricket Memorabilia by Marcus Williams and Gordon Philips, Queen Anne Press (1990). ISBN-13: 978-1852910549

Racing Art and Memorabilia: A Celebration of the Turf by Graham Budd. Publisher: Philip Wilson Publishers Ltd (2001). ISBN-10: 0856674850 ISBN-13: 978-0856674853

Close this window

From the ATG Archive

Stanley Matthews’ boots bring epic £32,000 bid

08 March 2010

THE 1953 FA Cup Final will forever be known as the Matthews Final.It was while playing for Blackpool against Bolton Wanderers that the legendary winger Sir Stanley Matthews (1915-2000) gave his career-defining performance and won the only major honour of a long career.

ATG Site Search

Changes unveiled for 2015 Summer Olympia

18 June 2014

In 2015, the Olympia International Art & Antiques Fair will move its dates to the end of June, running from June 18-28 to coincide with Masterpiece fair and the major Impressionist and modern art auctions.

Dealer News

Munnings hunting scene is hotly pursued in Salisbury

16 June 2014

When it comes to 20th century sporting pictures, there is no bigger name than Sir Alfred Munnings (1878-1959). Earlier this month, a sale at Woolley & Wallis in Salisbury sale saw the consignment of certainly one of the more notable works by the Mendham, Suffolk-born artist to have appeared in the regions over recent times.

Art Market